Occaisionally, an experimental
aircraft builder, given a choice of ring gears, will inquire
as to which one is "better" generally wondering if
the reduced number of teeth of the 122 would allow a faster
cranking RPM, etc. Well the answer is "absolutely
not." You must also consider the number of teeth on
the starter drive pinion will be different when matched to
each ring gear and effectively, the difference ends in a near
perfect wash.
The rhyme or reason as to why
Lycoming chose one ring gear over the other for particular
engines remains a complete mystery to all. One might
attempt to make the argument that the sturdier teeth on the
122 tooth gear was selected for the 720 models. But the
same person would be at a loss to explain why the same ring
gear was also used nearly exclusively on O-235 and O-290
engines and occasionally on -320 and -360 motors as
well.
Here's what we have experienced
broken down by engine series: